Best sunless tanning products?

I used to tan a lot in the summer but as I’ve gotten older I don’t want to sit out to get the color I want and damage my skin. I’ve done spray tans but don’t like how they start kinda patching off. What your favorite self tanner you’ve used? In the pictures id say I’m the first arm and am looking to get like a dark/liquid gold color but I want a product that people have had success with!